Water intrusion after a major renovation?

The $100,000 Exterior Renovation That Couldn’t Keep Water Out

The windows were new. The patio was new. The problem was new, too.

A Florida homeowner can spend $100,000 or more replacing impact windows and doors while renovating a patio or other exterior living space. The goal is usually straightforward: improve the home, protect it from Florida weather, and create an outdoor area the family can enjoy.

Then the rain comes.

Water appears around a window. A wall feels damp. Flooring near a door starts showing signs of moisture. Maybe water is getting into the patio or the interior of the home.

And suddenly, nobody seems to agree on why.

The Window Contractor Blames the Patio. The Patio Contractor Blames the Windows.

This is where a large exterior renovation can become complicated.

The window company may say its products are fine and point to the surrounding construction. The patio contractor may insist the water is coming through improperly installed windows or doors.

Another contractor may blame drainage, waterproofing, flashing, stucco, sealants, or work performed by someone else.

Meanwhile, the homeowner has a very expensive renovation that is not doing one of the most basic things it should do:

Keep water outside.

The Leak May Be Only the Beginning

Water intrusion can be deceptive.

The place where water becomes visible isn’t necessarily where it entered the building. Water can travel behind exterior finishes, walls and other building components before the homeowner ever sees it.

That means simply applying more sealant around the place where water appears may not solve the underlying problem.

A significant water-intrusion issue may require an engineer, building professional or other qualified expert to determine what failed and what needs to be repaired.

And once that investigation begins, the scope of the problem can grow.

The homeowner may discover that fixing the defect requires removing and reinstalling windows or doors, opening walls, repairing exterior finishes, addressing waterproofing or drainage, or redoing portions of recently completed patio work.

A project that already represented a major investment can suddenly carry another substantial repair bill.

When Multiple Contractors Are Involved, Responsibility Matters

Finding the defect is only part of the problem.

The next question is:

Who is responsible for it?

That can be difficult when several companies worked on interconnected parts of the project.

The answer may depend on much more than who performed the last repair.

Important evidence can include:

  • The construction contracts and individual scopes of work
  • Change orders
  • Architectural or engineering plans
  • Manufacturer installation requirements
  • Permit and inspection records
  • Photographs taken during construction
  • Emails and text messages with the contractors
  • Expert inspections and reports
  • Records of previous repair attempts

These documents can help establish what each contractor agreed to do, how the work was supposed to be performed and where the failure occurred.

Be Careful About the Endless Repair Cycle

When a contractor offers to come back and fix a problem, allowing a reasonable repair attempt may make sense.

But repeated repair attempts without understanding the cause can create a different problem.

Sealant gets added. Then more sealant. A section gets patched. Someone adjusts a door. Another contractor says to wait for the next rain.

Months can pass while the homeowner still doesn’t know why water is entering the home.

For a substantial construction problem, there is an important difference between giving a contractor an opportunity to address its work and allowing an unresolved defect to continue indefinitely.

Florida Construction Defect Claims Have Procedures and Deadlines

Florida law has specific requirements that may apply before a homeowner files a lawsuit involving alleged construction defects. Depending on the circumstances, those requirements can include providing notice and an opportunity for the responsible parties to inspect the alleged defects and respond.

Construction claims are also subject to legal deadlines.

That is one reason homeowners facing significant defects should not assume that continuing to negotiate with contractors indefinitely protects their legal rights.

A Major Renovation Deserves a Serious Response

An expensive window, door and patio project is not a minor home repair.

When a substantial exterior renovation results in continuing water intrusion, repeated unsuccessful repairs or potentially significant corrective work, the homeowner may need more than another contractor promising to “take a look.”

The contracts need to be reviewed. The evidence needs to be preserved. The cause of the problem needs to be identified. And responsibility needs to be sorted out before more time and money disappear into unsuccessful repairs.

Wyman Legal Solutions represents Florida homeowners in significant construction disputes involving defective work, failed renovations and substantial financial losses.

If your home has a serious construction problem involving significant damage or repair costs, call Wyman Legal Solutions at (561) 361-8700 to discuss your situation.

Facing significant repair costs? Call (561) 361-8700.